Video: Ishan Kishan’s Controversial Dismissal Sparks Debate in SRH vs. MI Clash

In a bizarre turn of events during Sunrisers Hyderabad’s (SRH) match against Mumbai Indians (MI), Ishan Kishan was dismissed under curious circumstances, leaving fans and experts puzzled. The left-hander attempted to glance a leg-side delivery from Deepak Chahar but seemingly missed the ball, only to walk off without any strong appeal from MI players. Umpire Vinod Seshan initially signaled a wide but changed his decision to ‘out’ after noticing Kishan’s spontaneous departure.

MI skipper Hardik Pandya even praised Kishan for his sportsmanship, but replays later suggested there was no edge, raising questions over the dismissal. The Ultra Edge technology, which detects bat-ball contact, showed no spike as the ball passed Kishan’s bat, implying he may not have nicked it. This marked the second time this season Kishan fell to a caught-behind down the leg side, further frustrating his campaign.

His early departure left SRH reeling at 9/2, and they soon collapsed to 35/5, struggling to recover against MI’s disciplined bowling attack. The incident has reignited debates over player walk-offs and the reliability of real-time umpiring decisions. With this loss, SRH’s dismal IPL 2025 season continues as they languish in ninth place, having won just two of their first seven matches. Their upcoming fixtures against Chennai Super Kings, Gujarat Titans, and Delhi Capitals will be crucial to keeping their playoff hopes alive.

Meanwhile, MI’s victory propelled them closer to the top four, with their next matches against Lucknow Super Giants, Rajasthan Royals, and Gujarat Titans set to define their campaign. The controversial dismissal has once again highlighted the fine margins in cricket, where split-second decisions—both by players and umpires—can dramatically alter a game’s outcome. While Kishan’s honesty was commendable, the lack of conclusive evidence has left fans wondering if technology should have overruled the on-field call, emphasizing the need for clearer protocols in such situations.